220 – The Hospitality SHE Suite: Jenna Fishel
by Cassady Quintana | October 29, 2026
What helps a woman build a lasting career in hospitality and find her voice as a leader? In this episode of the Hospitality SHE Suite, Cassady Quintana welcomes Jenna Fishel, Chief Commercial Officer at First Hospitality, to talk about growing into leadership. In their conversation, Jenna shares an honest perspective on finding your footing as a leader and why recognizing what’s possible for your career is essential. They discuss the power of supportive relationships, the courage to pursue new opportunities, and the importance of helping others grow. They also reflect on the responsibility companies have to retain talent, the value of voicing your ambitions, and the trust behind new opportunities. Tune in to learn how to build a career on your own terms with Jenna Fishel.
Cassady Quintana: Hello, everyone, and welcome to another episode of The Hospitality SHE Suite, a series where we highlight the awesome women leaving their mark on the hospitality industry. I’m your host, Cassady Quintana, and I’m so excited to bring you guys another great episode with our next guest, Jenna Fischel, Chief Commercial Officer at First Hospitality. Jenna, thank you so much for joining me.
Jenna Fishel: Absolutely. Thank you for having me. It’s a pleasure.
Cassady Quintana: Yeah, super excited for this episode. We have a lot of things we’re going to jump into, but I kind of want to go back to the beginning of your story just so our listeners can learn about you a little bit more. So talk to me about kind of how you found your way into hospitality and if that was always the plan for you when you were in college.
Jenna Fishel: Absolutely. So it definitely wasn’t the plan. I was going to college pursuing my Bachelor of Business Administration degree. And I happened to have a friend working at a local hotel at the front desk and was always telling me stories about work and she really enjoyed it. So I thought it could also be a good fit for me. A great mix of working with people, which I really enjoy, but then also allowing me the ability to practice some of the skills that I was learning in school. So I decided to apply, again, never thinking that this was going to be my career aspiration. However, I quickly learned that I loved working at the hotel more so than even going to school and started picking up more hours and taking on more responsibility.
Cassady Quintana: That’s awesome. Yeah. And I looked at your LinkedIn and noticed you’ve been at First Hospitality for 22 years, which first of all, congrats. That’s awesome. You don’t really see people staying at a company for that long and working their way up. So for you, take me back to when you first joined that company and what maybe initially brought you there. And over these past 22 years, what’s made you want to stay there too?
Jenna Fishel: Absolutely. And I get asked that quite often because, you’re right, you don’t hear a lot of people that are with one management company for that long. And overarching, I would just say, what’s kept me here so long is the people and the continuous investment in me as an individual, always having a mentor has been very beneficial and rewarding to me.
After starting at the front desk at a hotel in Michigan that was operated by First Hospitality, I was eventually promoted to front desk supervisor. I worked in the sales office briefly, and I was able to start sitting in on revenue meetings. I think we called it RevMax back in the day. And we had a binder out and printed out all the length of stay restrictions and where we were going to yield. And I just found this to be super fascinating and rewarding.
I started to run reports on my own, find opportunities to go in and add length of stay restrictions, re-bucket rate codes. And I was bringing these reports to my general manager every morning. And I think I probably exhausted him. And eventually, I earned his trust, and he started giving me the freedom to make all the changes on my own. So I could see where I was gravitating and what I found motivating. So that was very helpful. So I was thinking that was the path that I wanted to take and what I wanted to learn more about.
However, during this path, the general manager role came up and it was a step-up opportunity for me to take on more responsibility, get exposure to more leaders in our organization. So I took that role. And I was a general manager for four years. And in the first couple of years, I was really trying to grasp all aspects of the business, improve things. And my first year, I probably worked seven days a week just to get that hotel where it needed to be in terms of performance.
However, revenue management was always calling my name and that’s where I was gravitating. So I worked with some of the other leaders in our organization to do training on all the other brands. I was at Hilton Property, I learned Marriott, Hyatt, IHG, got certified in all the brands and started sitting on calls. So this was in addition to my current responsibility, but I had the exposure for this learning opportunity.
Eventually, yes, the company grew. We added in an additional regional revenue manager position and I was offered the job. And this was at the time when you had to be in-person for revenue management roles, in the office versus everything’s more remote now. So I relocated to Chicago, which, looking back, was a huge blessing to get to have the face time with more of our senior leaders.
And I was successful in that role, eventually promoted to corporate director of revenue, and then was our first vice president of revenue management. And during COVID, we all took on a lot of extra hats. And I had the privilege of also overseeing sales and marketing. With that additional responsibility, I was elevated to the title of Senior Vice President of Commercial Strategy, and then a couple years ago was elevated to Chief Commercial Officer at First Hospitality. It has definitely been an exciting journey.
Cassady Quintana: Yeah, you were the epitome of climbing that ladder, right? Literally, every door open when you needed it to, and you took those opportunities. It’s awesome to see. Because like we mentioned earlier, you see a lot of people jumping around because they want that different experience, but you were able to get that different experience and learn different things with staying with First Hospitality.
So like you mentioned, now you’re the CCO. For some of our listeners who may not be too familiar with what that position encompasses, talk us a little through what that looks like, especially in the hospitality industry. And then what are some areas that you’re responsible for today?
Jenna Fishel: Absolutely. So the simple answer is I support our three top line vertical; sales, revenue management, and marketing. I’m responsible for all the top line results. Some of those key metrics we look at are performance to budget, rep Par Index as an example for the entire portfolio. And I would say no day is like the previous day, no week is like the previous week. So it definitely keeps you engaged and interested and always learning.
I spend most of the time with my vertical leaders and other counterparts at First Hospitality, like operations and people services. There’s also always a sprinkle in there of maybe accounting or IT. And of course, our owners, team members and properties as well. And that’s one of the things that really drew me to this position is that I have the opportunity to work with so many different areas of the business.
Cassady Quintana: Yeah, yeah, for sure. And you know, with that, that growth that you’ve had within this company, I’m kind of curious to ask you about the other side, because I know it’s been a trend more recently of people not staying at a company for super long, because they either want to learn different things, or feel like they’re not growing. So have you ever felt that? Was there any point in your career with First Hospitality, or even in hospitality in general, where you were like, “Maybe I’m not feeling this anymore?” Or did you feel like once you got in it, like that was going to be your path for the future?
Jenna Fishel: Yeah, once I got in, I knew I was in the right lane, if I could describe it like that. And there are some people that probably are just naturally a little more complacent. And I would say I am a little more intrinsically motivated. There are definitely times through my career journey where it felt like I had been in a position a very long time, I was ready for the next step. And I used that extra opportunity, right? If I had everything firing on all cylinders, I would use that extra time to invest in my education or learning in other areas, so that when positions came up, I would be the first that came to mind.
And I would say I’m naturally curious and competitive and always want to raise the bar even higher. So that’s a great culture fit for me at First Hospitality, where we’re always striving to be the first to pilot new programs, the first to roll out a GEO playbook and so on. And you mentioned a lot of people don’t stay at companies for a long time or they leave to go to the next step. And I think that’s important for us to recognize internally. Because if we don’t provide that opportunity to our employees and they don’t see the path and we’re not consistently having those conversations, they’re going to go elsewhere. And that is likely a huge loss for the company.
Cassady Quintana: Yeah, no, I agree. I’m an older Gen Z. And one of the things when I started at Travel Media Group and this position I’m in now was that path of growth, right? A lot of people my age and this younger generation want to be loyal to a company, but either they don’t have that path forward, it’s not laid out by their boss, or they feel like it’s not been talked about, like you said. So having those conversations with the younger generation, or it can be someone older too, who just started with that company. If there’s no path forward or they don’t have something to work toward to or look forward to. And especially like you mentioned, some of these positions were created and then you were a good fit for that. Things like that are important too.
So I kind of want to transition into that leadership because you have gone from being towards the bottom of the totem pole, like they say, and worked your way up. So how has your leadership style evolved? Because it’s one thing where you’re really good at your job and you kind of do your own thing, but it’s another thing to lead a group of people. So how have you learned your leadership style along the way and how has that grown, I would say?
Jenna Fishel: Absolutely. So if I look back to when I was a general manager as an example, which was probably like my first big leadership role of a larger team, when I look back, I was pretty awful, right? I wish I had shown up differently. And I think about how I’ve grown. And back then, I would say I definitely stuck to the rules and the expectations and did not have enough human elements of compassion that came through.
And being a young leader, I didn’t understand at that point in my life that everyone prioritized their career differently. And everyone had a different view of what work-life balance looked like. And I have spent a lot of time through the years in personal coaching, group coaching to help me be more aware of where my leadership gaps are. And I would say it is still a continuous process. And I still have a lot of areas of opportunity to continue to grow. I’m not done yet.
Cassady Quintana: There you go. I mean, you should never be done learning. That’s what life is all about. Especially in this industry, it is changing every day. And there’s something you learn new at a show you go to. I go on LinkedIn and learn something new every day too. It’s crazy how much hospitality changes and how quickly it changes, especially with – we won’t get into the whole AI conversation, but who knows where we’ll be in the beginning of next year and what we’ll be talking about then.
Jenna Fishel: Absolutely.
Cassady Quintana: Kind of on that same realm of leadership, a lot of the reason I wanted to start this series of our podcast is because one, there’s nobody else doing it. But two, hospitality is such a male dominated industry. And we are seeing that that is changing. You were just on a panel at the Hotel Data Conference of all women, which was super cool to see. And we’re starting to see that more. But I want to know what your experience has been like as you’ve gone through and now you’re in this C-suite. What’s it like being a woman going through that? What’s it like being a woman on a C -suite? And if there’s any people that along the way kind of mentored you to that? I mean, I know on my last podcast, Kat was talking about how there was men that helped her get to where she was and she wouldn’t have been able to without them. So I kind of just want to know about your experience with that.
Jenna Fishel: Absolutely. I feel very strongly that we need men as allies and mentors throughout the process. And I would say I’ve had both women and men that have been asked impactful and supportive of my career. For example, when my general manager was leaving before I got that role, he helped advocate for me. I did not have a lot of experience being the number two in the hotel. I had been in that position for less than a year. And he went to bat for me and said, “You may find someone more experienced, but you’ll never find someone as good and committed as she is.” Right? So he advocated for me to get into the first general manager role.
I have also worked for amazing women that I feel are very inspiring, made you feel valued, always invited you to meetings for introductions and to give you exposure into different areas. However, again, men have been just as impactful. I had one leader as an example who I was vocalizing my career aspirations because they say women don’t aspire to be as high on the ladder as men do, just the way they were groomed or how we think. So that was very eye-opening to me. I was like, I’m going to change that and I am going to vocalize this. I’m going to tell my boss that my aspiration is going to be our chief commercial officer at First Hospitality.
And I was all nervous to have this conversation thinking I was being big and I was bold and brave. And his response will sit with me forever. He said, “Jenna, that’s great. However, you need to think bigger.” He’s like, “You should be aiming for my seat.” And I was like, “Wow.” I share that because it’s powerful and that sits with me. And I want all women to just continue to think, even if you think you’re thinking big, men are probably thinking a little bit bigger. Think higher.
Cassady Quintana: Yeah, I love that. And that kind of goes into my next question, because when I see women in leadership, they just have this confidence and this aura, if you will, about them and they just exude that. And so you kind of think like, “Oh yeah, they’ve just been a boss their whole life.”
Was there ever a point where you got into these different leadership positions and you maybe didn’t have that confidence? I mean, you just mentioned him telling you to think bigger and be bigger, but did you ever get into a position and maybe were scared or questionable about what you thought you could do?
Jenna Fishel: So many times I questioned myself for what my abilities were. And people say stick to your intuition. And I would say that’s so true. It cannot be said enough. And something else that has also helped me significantly is build an army of supporters around you that support you and you’re going to support them equally, because it takes a whole village, right, to really lead. And it’s important that I think you’re transparent with the people you work with and you have that. So you can go to them and say, like, “Ham I showing up? Or could I have done this better?” so that you’re getting consistent feedback, whether that be from an internal trusted partner or an executive coach in some cases.
Cassady Quintana: Yeah, I think that’s important having that supportive group around you, because like you mentioned earlier, you’re always learning. And even though your title may say one thing, there may be somebody that knows more about a specific topic than you do. So still being open to listening to those underneath you, getting other opinions, things like that’s only going to make you grow as leaders is something I’ve definitely learned.
And I want to talk about continuing that path that you’re on right now of it’s not always the easiest road to get where you are. You’ve been with First Hospitality for 22 years. When you tell me that story, it sounds great, right? You were ready for something new, a position opened up, it all worked out. But I’m sure behind the scenes, there were other things at play there. So was there ever a moment for you that at the time felt like a setback, but now you look back and you’re like, “There was a reason for that?” I mean, it can be personal or professional.
Jenna Fishel: Yeah, absolutely. And I think one thing to share is just because I’ve been promoted a lot internally doesn’t mean that these promotions or opportunities were just granted to me. I did have to speak up and advocate. And I always tell everyone there’s always room at the top. And just because positions don’t exist now doesn’t mean they won’t in three years or five years. And we have to keep thinking like that to create these positions and to grow ourselves.
I mean, there’s definitely been times where I advocated for myself and I was straight out told no. Of course, in the moment, it feels very defeating. And sometimes you can revisit those opportunities sooner than later. I’m a big advocate for timing is right, whether the person is open to conversation and feedback at the time. However, there’s been times I told no, I regrouped, came back with probably a better story initiative or why this was great for the organization, and eventually landed the additional responsibility that I was looking for.
Cassady Quintana: Yeah, I love that. I love that. So when you think about yourself as a leader and you strip away the title and everything you’ve accomplished at First Hospitality, what do you want your team, the people underneath you, or even just your peers to remember about you as a leader? What kind of mark do you want to leave on them?
Jenna Fishel: Yeah, I want everyone to feel the sky is the limit. And my story can be your story. And maybe it’s not 22 years at First Hospitality, but you can pave your own career path. And if you’re working for the right people and having the right conversations, you can be just as successful as I feel I’ve been at First Hospitality in your current company or migrating through different companies.
Cassady Quintana: That kind of makes me think about the whole glass ceiling that we talk about. For you, it seems like there is no ceiling at all. And that’s kind of what you want your team to feel, which I love. I feel that same way and have that same fire of like, “Well, why not?” We can try. And if it doesn’t work, then we know. And we just keep doing different things. I kind of like that imagery of the sky is the limit, but let’s go even further kind of thing.
We’ve talked a lot about your career, Jenna, and everything you’ve accomplished at First Hospitality, but I do like to have some fun on this podcast. So when you’re not CCO at First Hospitality, what are the things or the moments that make you feel the most like yourself?
Jenna Fishel: Absolutely. I am a mom, most importantly, of two. I do have a five-year-old daughter and almost eight-year-old son. So as you can imagine, it takes up a lot of time and it’s very rewarding. And I would say it’s also made me a better boss because I’ve been forced to have a work-life balance. And outside of that, I have been very dedicated to my Orangetheory classes the last couple of years. I find a lot of enjoyment on that. And I’m also a big Michigan football fan. So I sprinkle that through my week, especially this fall during football season.
Cassady Quintana: I was going to say, it’s going to be a bit – I’m a Florida Gator fan. So we don’t really play each other too much. So I guess we continue to be friends through that.
Jenna Fishel: Absolutely.
Cassady Quintana: That’s awesome. A work-life balance is super important, especially I feel like after the pandemic, we’ve really, really honed in on that and understanding that family’s important, our mental health is important, our physical health is important. So it’s good to see that someone as successful as you is still being able to balance all of those things. And that helps other people feel like they can do the same.
So kind of a little bit of a deeper question, but if you could go back to younger Jenna at the beginning of her hospitality career, what’s a piece of advice you would give her?
Jenna Fishel: Sure. I would say that who you hire and who you build as your team is just as important for anything that you do for your own personal development. And I would say hire people that are smarter than you, experts in what they do and have the confidence that you can lead them and build a team. And don’t be afraid to hire people that might be compensated higher than you are. Because it doesn’t take anything away from you. It is going to make your hotel entity vertical, more successful, by bringing on top talent. And the success that that individual sees and the team sees is really a reflection back on your results.
Cassady Quintana: I love that. That’s a great piece of advice for all of us, younger generation, all the women that will be listening to this podcast. I love that. All right. So to wrap up, Jenna, when you look ahead at what’s next for First Hospitality, the industry and yourself, what are you most excited about? And then also for our listeners, where can they find you? Where can they find First Hospitality?
Jenna Fishel: Absolutely. AI is definitely on the forefront. And I would say First Hospitality, I’m very thankful, has taken a huge stake in this area. We have an AI committee led by our executive chairman, Sam Schwartz, who is very passionate about this. And again, feel very fortunate. It feels like a lot in the moment, right? All the different trainings and forcing yourself to do things. But I can already see how it’s going to put us further ahead in the future by taking the time to do this. By being more productive, less manual work, we will have measurably better results with what we’re producing and the ability to measure the progress.
And it allows us to be radically transparent with our owners, as we give them more visibility into our data and results with these tools and helps us better align as owners. I just feel very excited that we’ve invested in the AI development of the individuals at First Hospitality and then as an organization. So very excited to see where this goes. And in months, this isn’t years, right? It’s every month there’s progress as an industry.
Cassady Quintana: Well, that’s awesome. We’ll definitely make sure to keep an eye out for First Hospitality and everything you guys are doing there. It’s going to be awesome to see. And like we said earlier, this is going to be a few months and it’s going to change again. So definitely for our listeners, keep up with First Hospitality and Jenna and everything they’re doing over there.
But Jenna, thank you so much for joining me today. It’s been a pleasure getting to know you and talk to you and learn about your story. Hopefully, we’ll see you at another upcoming show.
Jenna Fishel: Thank you. And yes, and please follow First Hospitality on LinkedIn just to hear more about upcoming news, new hotel openings and exciting initiatives.
Cassady Quintana: For sure. I definitely will. So I recommend our listeners do the same. Well, thank you, Jenna, again for joining The SHE Suite. Super excited for our listeners to hear this conversation and for everyone tuned into this episode, thank you so much for taking the time out of your day and giving this a listen. And we will see you next time on The Hospitality SHE Suite.
Jenna Fishel: Thank you
To make sure you never miss a conversation, be sure to subscribe, leave a five-star review, and follow us on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or your favorite podcast app. I’m your host, Cassady Quintana, and I hope this conversation inspires you to continue supporting, elevating, and celebrating the women shaping hospitality today and for generations to come.




0 Comments